Ingenious Wheels

Rixer

New member
I am curious to know how many railroad buffs know what keeps the wheels of a train on the tracks. The first answer that comes to mind, which is wrong, are the flanges. The flanges on the wheels actually are not necessary, and are only there as an insurance policy for engineers who take corners a little faster than they probably should. The physics of a railroad wheel is actually more subtle. If you look at the cross-section of a wheel on a track, you will notice that the wheel does not sit flat on the track, but is beveled. And the bevel increases dramatically as the tread approaches the flange. The reason for the bevel is that it changes the radius of the wheel. For the physics to work, the wheels on an axle must be fixed and not be free to rotate independently. As a wheel rides up to "jump" the track, the larger radius of the bevel causes it to rotate slower (large wheels rotate slower than small wheels at the same speed). Consequently, the wheel on the opposite rail moves such that it contacts the rail at a smaller radius. It would like to rotate faster, but it can't because the wheels aren't free to rotate independently. It's beautifully complicated, but the bottom line is that it forces the truck to turn inward, centering it on both rails. Try putting a large wheel and a small wheel on the same axle and watch how it rolls. This process actually is continuous and automatic, so the wheels will stay centered on the rails, unless Casey Jones is going too fast. Then the squealing sound of rail on flanges will be heard, which, by the way, is nicely built into the Trainz program.

Jim
 
That's why "outlaws" on dirt oval tracks use one large and one small tire, right? Go around the turns fast.
 
Excellent post! I always thought that the wheel flanges were mandatory because as your going around a curve, wouldn't centripetal force make the train slide off the track if you were without wheel flanges? Banking on curves dramatically reduces the effect of centripetal forces but some curves dont have banking.
 
Without flanges, even on perfect track, a train would derail in short order, within a very short distance, even at 1mph.

Yes ... The Physics of the bevel of the wheeltread, and beveled railhead does work, scientificly, but even a carefull engineer would derail if not for flanges. There is a video somewhere of a train wheel "Hunting" and the wheeltread actually lifts off of the railhead.

On any curve the inward wheel takes the shortest distance, and the outer wheel slides along (or vice versa), and would derail at all times if not for flanges, no matter how well banked the track was ... it would always derail.
 
Last edited:
Without flanges, even on perfect track, a train would derail in short order, within a very short distance, even at 1mph.

Yes ... The Physics of the bevel of the wheeltread, and beveled railhead does work, scientificly, but even a carefull engineer would derail if not for flanges. There is a video somewhere of a train wheel "Hunting" and the wheeltread actually lifts off of the railhead.

On any curve the inward wheel takes the shortest distance, and the outer wheel slides along (or vice versa), and would derail at all times if not for flanges, no matter how well banked the track was ... it would always derail.

Indeed. Not to mention materiel deflection and uneven wear due to bad brake rigging.

Wheels may have been manufactured with a tapered tread, but a 30-40 ton axle-loading will flatten it right out.
 
Hi Cascade:

Are you really at Vostok Station? In my physical chemistry professoring days, I did a lot of work with ice core data from Vostok. Anyway, I don't believe you are correct about the 1 mph statement. The wheel flange is not supposed to come into contact with the railhead. The wheels are supposed to be able to slide back and forth to allow the train to corner. In any case, the sinusoidal behavior of the wheel set is a natural consequence of the conical shape of the wheel tread. Excessive "hunting" really is only a problem as the wheel tire wears and at high speeds. With all the global warming going on, you guys should see palm trees at any time now.

Jim
 
Back
Top